Answer by Robert Rapplean for Why are scout bots only used for reconnaissance?
Let's start by considering a spy-bot in the form of a quadcopter drone. Its job is to move a camera and transmitter around. Right now, you can do this with a reasonable amount of autonomous...
View ArticleAnswer by Iiridayn for Why are scout bots only used for reconnaissance?
Two reasons immediately come to mind:First, as others have mentioned, there could be laws or mores in place to restrict this use. This is relatively simple to justify to a reader, but doesn't answer...
View ArticleAnswer by Ruadhan for Why are scout bots only used for reconnaissance?
Poor ReplaceabilityThe Scout-bots aren't exactly cheap, all those rare-earth metals in their leg-servos and sensors and other expensive parts mean that they're not disposable for a civilisation...
View ArticleAnswer by Pica for Why are scout bots only used for reconnaissance?
Scouts are using themselves up to propell themselves.Basically a scout is a camera on a fuel stack circling - and they need energy to transmit, to function and to move. For that they consume there...
View ArticleAnswer by Denys Zheliezniak for Why are scout bots only used for reconnaissance?
Scouting implements are expensive and fragile. When push comes to shove the robot can defend itself, but it's risky and looks pretty bad on cost-benefit analysis to use the scout robots as fighting...
View ArticleAnswer by Ángel for Why are scout bots only used for reconnaissance?
The first point is that nobody likes having killing robots around.Civilians really hate the idea. A basic reason this society accepted robots was the concept that "A robot will never harm a human...
View ArticleAnswer by The Square-Cube Law for Why are scout bots only used for...
If you make fighting robots which are 100% autonomous, getting offed by them will be a matter of time.Humans are needed because humans call the shots. The day humans stop calling the shots is the day...
View ArticleAnswer by DKNguyen for Why are scout bots only used for reconnaissance?
The governing Computer Council has put forth an edict that only humans will be sent into combat against human soldiers, so as to preserve the loss of robot life since human can heal and self-replicate,...
View ArticleAnswer by TheDemonLord for Why are scout bots only used for reconnaissance?
Some thoughts:WeightThe robot carry various scouting tools, mapping tools, surveillance tools etc. and these are all heavy. This means that it doesn't have the capacity to carry any extra dedicated...
View ArticleAnswer by Mary for Why are scout bots only used for reconnaissance?
Scouts are specialized functions. You program the scout to do that and nothing else. This produces a robot that is very poorly suited to do anything else.So why not make a specialized battle bot? Or...
View ArticleAnswer by Joachim for Why are scout bots only used for reconnaissance?
My comment was in jest, but actually contains an answer as well: these scout robots are not made for combat. And there is a huge range of reasons this might not be the case. A few broad...
View ArticleAnswer by Trish for Why are scout bots only used for reconnaissance?
LatencyBots get commands, decrypt them, and then move, make telemetry and image data, encrypt them, and send the parcel back. Data is decrypted, then a human decides what to do next. As a result, all...
View ArticleAnswer by Starfish Prime for Why are scout bots only used for reconnaissance?
combat-capable autonomous robotsdoes not necessarily imply "human-level intelligence capable of dealing with all of the situations that may arise once the shooting has stopped". Human environments and...
View ArticleAnswer by L.Dutch for Why are scout bots only used for reconnaissance?
The enemy can easily hack them and make them switch side.Losing a scout to an enemy is a rather little damage, compared with giving them a monster attack machine. Better send human soldiers, which in...
View ArticleWhy are scout bots only used for reconnaissance?
Why would scout robots be used for recon only, not general combat?I have a situation in which scout robots akin to mars rovers are used for military applications by forces residing on a foreign planet...
View ArticleAnswer by komodosp for Why are scout bots only used for reconnaissance?
The robots are tinyThe enemy have powerful anti-robot countermeasures, (EMP weapons or what have you). So our heroes have found the best way of maintaining stealth is for the robots themselves to be...
View ArticleAnswer by Creative Mania for Why are scout bots only used for reconnaissance?
While sending robotic scouts with lethal capabilities has advantages, here are some reasons why humans might still be required for the final confrontation:Decision-making and adaptability: While your...
View Article